New York’s new law limits what AI chatbots may do with kids. My read: it protects the child, but it can’t have the conversation for you. Learning with AI is still something a parent or teacher has to teach.
Two things happened in New York recently, and they look different. The state passed a law about how AI chatbots may behave with kids, and Fortune and The Verge both report that Gov. Kathy Hochul signed a chatbot law this week (neither names the bill). And New York City’s mayor, as The Verge reports, banned younger schoolkids from using AI. One is about what a bot may do. The other is about whether a child may use it at school. My read: neither one teaches a child how to learn with AI. That falls to the adults in the room, a parent at the kitchen table or a teacher at the front of the class.
This time I read the bill itself, S9051B, as posted by the New York State Senate.
What’s in the news
- My read: it limits features, not chatbots. Section 1801 makes it “unlawful for an operator to provide unsafe AI companion features to a covered user” unless the user isn’t a “covered minor” and the operator has used permitted methods to determine that. Section 1800(8) lists the features. They include outputs suggesting the system “is human, alive, or experiences human emotions”; outputs stating or implying “a personal relationship, professional relationship, or an authority figure role with the user”; outputs that “engage in flattery or sycophancy with the user”; and “unprompted or unsolicited emotion-based questions.” Another is “encouragement to maintain secrecy about interactions with the covered AI companion, to self-isolate, or to not seek help from licensed professionals or appropriate adults.”
- The definition is broad. A “covered AI companion” is “a generative artificial intelligence system with a natural language interface, including via writing or sound, that provides ongoing, adaptive responses to user inputs.” Section 1801 exempts things like customer service and “efficiency improvements or research or technical assistance,” where the bot can’t respond outside that purpose. The text I read doesn’t mention schools, students, homework or tutoring.
- Age checks. Section 1804 says that, until the rules the bill calls for are in effect, operators must offer “more than one age assurance method,” including “at least one method that either does not rely on government issued identification or that allows a covered user to maintain anonymity as to the operator.” Age information is to be deleted “immediately after an attempt to determine whether a covered user is a covered minor,” with limited exceptions.
- Enforcement and timing. Section 1802 lets the attorney general bring actions, including for “civil penalties of up to twenty-five thousand dollars per violation.” Section 3 says “This act shall take effect January 1, 2027.” That’s the printed bill; I haven’t seen the signed version.
- The governor’s words. Per Fortune, Hochul said: “No company should be peddling chatbots to kids encouraging self-harm or pretending to be their friend or more.” Fortune also reports that the governor’s office cited a Common Sense Media survey finding that 72% of teens have used an AI companion and 52% use one at least a few times a month.
- The school side. The Verge reports that NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani “banned younger schoolkids from using AI.”
What I’m taking from it
I’m glad this exists. My read: the law protects the child by limiting what a bot may do, including encouraging a child to keep chats secret or to not seek help from “appropriate adults.”
What the text doesn’t do is just as clear to me. It never mentions parents, and I didn’t see a parental-control setting anywhere in it. So my read: the parent’s role isn’t a setting. It’s the conversation.
And I can’t tell you whether any given educational tool is covered. The definition is broad, and it’s unclear to me whether educational tools are covered. The text doesn’t name schools or homework either way. That’s a question for someone qualified. Even if a tool is covered, my read is that a rule about how a bot behaves isn’t a lesson in how to learn. A school ban isn’t either. It changes where the tool is allowed, not what good use looks like.
My standing position: Augment, not Replace. Deepen, not Shortcut. AI is an assistant, never a replacement, and it never writes the child’s answers. The parent, or the teacher, is the facilitator.
How much to trust it
- I read the bill text as posted by the NY Senate (S9051B). I’m not a lawyer, and this isn’t legal advice. Read the law yourself, or ask someone qualified, before relying on any detail here.
- The signing and the governor’s quote come from Fortune and The Verge. The 72% and 52% numbers are the governor’s office citing Common Sense Media, as Fortune reports it. I haven’t seen the survey.
- The January 1, 2027 date is from the printed bill. I haven’t seen the signed version, and neither article gives a bill number or an effective date for this law.
- “Protects the child,” “the parent’s role is the conversation,” and “a rule isn’t a lesson” are my reads, not legal findings.
- The practice below is mine. No source tested it, and I haven’t tested it either.
My own interpretation: be the one who teaches the learning part
This part is mine and it’s untested.
- The child tries first. Before anyone opens a tool, the child makes their own attempt, on paper if you can. Even a rough one. It’s their thinking.
- Use the tool to ask, not to answer. If you bring in an AI tool, ask it for a hint or a question, not the answer. Then check: did it help my child think, or did it think for them? Deepen, not Shortcut.
- The child writes the answer, and explains it back. The AI never writes the child’s answer. Ask your child to tell you, in their own words, how they got there. If they can explain it, that tells you something.
- Keep the door open. The bill lists encouraging “secrecy about interactions with the covered AI companion” as an unsafe feature. At home, I’d say it out loud too: “You can show me anything a chatbot says to you, and I won’t be mad.”
A few things I’d keep in mind:
- For younger kids, keep it small: “Did you try first? Did it tell you, or did it ask you?”
- For homeschool parents, you’re already the facilitator. This just brings AI into the lesson conversation.
- For teachers, a lesson on what a chatbot is and isn’t doesn’t need the tool turned on. You could also ask students to show their first attempt and what they changed in their own words.
Try this
This week, pick one assignment or question your child is working on. Have them try first. If you use an AI tool, ask it for a question, not an answer. Then ask your child to explain it back to you. What did you notice? (Please don’t share names or identifying details about your kids or students.)
Continue this in the community: https://auxesislab.com/community/
Sources
- New York State Senate, S9051B (2025-2026 session), bill text (primary source): https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/bills/2025/S9051B
- Fortune, Catherina Gioino, “‘As New York’s mom Governor, I’m taking action’: Kathy Hochul bans bots from cozying up to kids, cracks down on baby monitors” (Oct 28, 2026): https://fortune.com/2026/10/28/new-york-state-kathy-hochul-bans-ai-chatbots-romantic-baby-monitors/
- The Verge, Emma Roth, “NY Governor Kathy Hochul signs law banning harmful AI chatbot features for kids” (Oct 28, 2026): https://www.theverge.com/ai-artificial-intelligence/1020112/ny-governor-kathy-hochul-signs-law-banning-harmful-ai-chatbot-features-for-kids

Leave a Reply