On Oct 29, the Defense Department’s school system posted draft requirements for an AI tutor. Its draft rules sound a lot like the ones I care about: the tool guides, the adult stays in charge.

On Oct 29, 2026, the Defense Department’s school system (DoDEA) posted a public notice on SAM.gov, the federal contracting site. It is a “Sources Sought” notice, which is market research. The notice says it “is issued solely for information and planning purposes” and “is not a solicitation or Request for Proposal (RFP).” It also says it “does not commit the Government to issue a solicitation or award a contract.”

So this is not a purchase. It is a school system writing down what it would want from an AI tutor and asking what’s out there. One naming note: the notice uses its own labels, “DoWEA” for the agency and “SI” for AI. I’m using DoDEA and “AI tutor” so this stays easy to read.

What the notice describes

The notice describes a tool for grades 3-8, “covering approximately 30,200 students and 6,000 educators.” That’s a big system, and my read is that its draft is worth reading even if you never go near a federal contract.

Here are the parts that caught my eye. These are quotes from the public notice only.

  • Guide, don’t solve. The tutoring is meant to use “scaffolded learning supports to guide students toward answers without direct generation of solutions.”
  • A guardrail on graded work. It lists “system guardrails preventing wholesale answer generation for graded assignments.”
  • No pretend friend. “The system shall not adopt names, conversational personas, romantic/companion behaviors, or humanlike characteristics.”
  • The teacher holds the keys. Access would use “Teacher-gated/assignment-gated usage control modes,” and the notice says “Grade and score releases are strictly restricted to manual, explicit teacher verification.”
  • A dashboard for the teacher. The draft lists a teacher dashboard that would show, among other items, “student usage patterns, misconceptions” and “overreliance flags.”
  • Families get plain words. The notice asks for “Plain-language transparency notices detailing system strengths, limitations, and the role of human oversight,” and for resources on “responsible learning support at home.”

The notice also lists federal student-privacy and security requirements. I’m leaving those to people who can speak to them properly.

Why it matters to me

I’ve said for a while that the parent is the facilitator and AI is an assistant, never a replacement. I also think a tool should ask questions, not write answers. Augment, not Replace. Deepen, not Shortcut.

I’m not claiming DoDEA agrees with me on everything. My read: when a system this size sat down to write what it wants, a good share of the list was about keeping the thinking with the student and the decisions with the adult. For me that’s useful, because it gives parents and teachers plain language to use.

How much to trust it

  • This is a draft from a market research notice. It describes what DoDEA says it wants. It doesn’t tell us whether any tool does these things, whether a contract will ever be awarded, or whether anyone is bidding.
  • The notice has other goals too. It says the aim is “to measurably improve student learning outcomes and engagement while significantly reducing teacher preparation and administrative workloads.” The teacher-facing side includes tools that draft lesson plans and quizzes. I’m focused on the student-facing rules only.
  • I’m quoting only the public notice text.
  • I haven’t tested any tool against these rules. The three checks below are my own translation, and they’re untested.

My own interpretation: three checks for any AI tool

This part is mine. Use it with a tool you’re considering, whether you’re a parent at the kitchen table or a teacher with a class.

  1. Does it guide, or does it answer? Try it yourself, as the adult, on a sample question like the ones your child works on. Does it ask a question back, or hand over the solution? If it just answers, my read is that the thinking gets skipped.
  2. Is there a persona pretending to be a friend? A name, a personality, a “buddy” voice. The notice rules that out for its tool. I’d want to know why a homework helper needs one.
  3. Is the adult right there, and does the adult decide what counts? Are you sitting with your child while it’s used? Do you decide what gets used, and what’s your child’s own work? At home, that adult is the parent.

A few things to keep in mind:

  • For younger kids, sitting beside them, keep it small: “Did you try first? Did it tell you, or did it ask you?”
  • For homeschool parents, you’re already the facilitator. This just gives you three questions to bring to a tool.
  • For teachers, these checks might give you language for a conversation with your school or district about what you’d want a tool to do.
  • For any tool, check its age rules and privacy settings first, and keep kids’ names and personal details out of it.

Try this

Pick one AI tool you’ve seen or used, and run it through the three checks this week. Then let me know what you found. Did it guide, or did it answer?

Continue this in the community: https://auxesislab.com/community/ Which of these checks would you add or change? Please don’t share kids’ names or identifying details, yours or anyone else’s.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *